[Sorry for the late posting, all. There was some family health drama this past week that slowed me down.]
A feminist in the generation that followed Miller, how could I not fall deeply into this book? An English major in the 1980s; taking tentative, widely-ridiculed Women’s Studies classes on a recently “co-ed” campus; an experienced friend (my childhood besties are still my besties) but having to learn how to navigate friendship around the new obstacles of romances. We read Kristeva, took classes with Marianne Hirsch, flirted with/had affairs with young male professors. “Quotation turned into performance,” though we didn’t know it. Also history repeats itself…
I also respect that she named names – M. Riffaterre!
What I loved about this book, apart from the recognition, was how Miller writes the magnificence of friendships (like her, I’d also say “women’s friendships,” but I’m going to guess that there would be pushback against that idea now), regardless of how they ended. Despite memory lapses, ethical questions, and “bad” endings, she captures so much of the beauty of love: celebration of the beloved, passion, vulnerability, forgiveness. She was able to remember! What a gift!
I was also grateful to read about friendship and sudden loss/grief as I try to figure out if/what I might write.


Yes re: naming names. Knuckle / breast, 23 year olds who are too old… grrr. Love your use of “experienced friend.” (My childhood bestie is still my bestie, too.) Hope everyone is feeling better.
Karen, I think your first comment about the health drama grabbed my attention right away because of my own family health drama. As women I think we are often most effected, because we tend to be the caregivers- an expected role. This made me wonder about Carolyns family. Her husband was mentioned but not her children.
I also looked forward to this book for the reasons you mentioned. It did not disappoint, though I want to read it again, more slowly, just for myself, and maybe with my own brilliant friends.
I was also struck that she “named names.” I thought it was great. Here in the UK there are really strict libel rules so I have gone around for the last two years never “naming names.” SO it really struck me, and I was interested that you noticed it too. What a rat!